1796 - The Original House
Fisher began work on his original house in the summer of 1796, shortly after his arrival in Blue Hill in June of that year. The frame of the house was raised on September 1st, and without a doubt most of the men in his congregation were on hand to assist.
The Fishers did not occupy their house for over a year. On November 2, 1797 (the day of their first wedding anniversary), Jonathan and Dolly Battle Fisher finally took up residence on their homestead. The Parson writes in his journal:
"This day we are removed into our own house. Though in an unfinished state, it is more comfortable than the habitations of many."
The Fishers’ original house was quite small, being only one-and-a-half stories tall, with two rooms on the ground floor and a small sleeping space under the roof. But for a newly-wed couple on the Maine frontier it was comfortable.
1814 – The Big House
By the second decade of the nineteenth century, it became apparent that the Fisher home was becoming too small for the growing family and the Parson began to plan a substantial addition to his house. In 1811, perhaps in anticipation of this activity, Fisher constructed a wood house in his yard. In it he installed the first wind-powered saw in Blue Hill.
Fisher continued preparations for his house in the following years. During the long winter months of 1814, the Parson began to draw up plans for his house. He created several different schemes, and settled on the final form of the building in February of that year.
On January 18, 1814, Fisher “engaged Mr. J. Holt to frame my house for me next June,” and also he “engaged Mr. Savage to enclose the covering of my house, put on corner boards, window facings, & trimmings...by the last of Sept. 1814.”
The Parson kept to this schedule, and on June 21, 1814, the frame of Fisher’s house was raised into place:
"A day of care & business—Mr. Holt, Steven & Mr. Smith worked A. M. on frame. Worked myself stripping old house & drawing nails. About 100 hand collected & assisted me in raising my house, with plank sides, which went up well, & no person was materially hurt. After raising partook of a bountiful supper & after supper had pleasant singing. Blessed be God for the variety & abundance of his mercies."
It took several more years for Jonathan Fisher to complete his house. His journal records that the Parson was working to finish the building well into 1818, at which time he finally painted the exterior.